You have found two ways to explore medicine, and both sound interesting. One asks you to pitch an idea. The other gives you a cohort and a mentor while you build a project. Which should come first? Start with how you want to work, not which name sounds more impressive.

Start with the Fellowship if you want a mentor and a finished project built over eight weeks. Start with the Challenge if you want a focused, self-driven test of one idea before judges. You can also do both, one after the other, rather than choosing forever.

Jump to section

What each one is

The Challenge

The Global Pre-Med Challenge is an individual competition for Grades 8 to 12. Its single track is Public Health & Medical Innovation. You identify a health problem and propose an original way to address it.

Round One asks for a video pitch. Finalists move to a live round, where judges question the idea. The task is not just to sound convincing. You need to explain the problem, your proposed solution and why it could work.

The Challenge page lists prizes and scholarships. It currently says every entrant receives a scholarship toward a Learn With Leaders online program. Check the Challenge recognition and current terms rather than assuming every award has the same conditions. For fees, dates, deadlines and session details, check the page for current details.

The Fellowship

The Future Doctors Fellowship is a live online cohort for Grades 8 to 12. It runs over eight weeks, with Harvard undergraduate mentors and cohorts of 15 to 20 students. You finish with a capstone project.

The difference is the working setup. You join a group and have mentor guidance while developing your work. You are not entering a judged competition simply by joining the Fellowship.

For fees, upcoming cohorts and session details, check the page for current details. The programs guide also helps you place the Fellowship alongside the site's other options.

Side by side

What to compareGlobal Pre-Med ChallengeFuture Doctors Fellowship
FormatOnline competition with a video-pitch round and a live round for finalistsLive online program over eight weeks
GradesGrades 8 to 12Grades 8 to 12
How you take partIndividual entryCohort of 15 to 20 students
Mentor contactMentor-led masterclasses; do not assume individual project supervisionHarvard undergraduate mentors guiding the cohort
What you produceA video pitch for a public health or medical innovation idea; a live pitch if selectedA capstone project
How it is judgedJudges assess the pitch and, for finalists, responses to questions using the listed criteriaA capstone and Demo Day; the page does not describe a competition ranking
Best forYou want to work independently and test an idea before judgesYou want structure and guidance while building a project

That last row is a starting point, not a label you have to keep. You can enjoy competition and still want help with your first project.

Who should start where

You like competing and working alone

Consider the Challenge first. It gives your idea a clear destination: a pitch that someone else will assess. You will need to make choices without waiting for a cohort to make them with you.

Before entering, read what judges look for in a pre-med competition. If explaining the weak points in your own idea sounds interesting rather than just scary, this format may suit you.

You want guidance and structure

Consider the Fellowship first. A mentor and a cohort may be the setup you want when a project still feels vague. You can work toward a finished capstone over eight weeks instead of starting with the pressure of a judged entry.

Look at the Fellowship format, then browse the student project showcase. Treat those projects as examples to inspect, not promises about what your own work will look like.

You are in Grade 8

Both options include your grade. You do not need to choose the competition just because you are eligible, or avoid it because you are younger.

Ask yourself two questions: Can I stay with one idea when the first version does not work? Do I want someone helping me decide what to do next? Your answers matter more than trying to seem advanced.

You are new to medicine

Start with curiosity. Can you name one health problem you would like to understand? You do not need a complicated invention before you have a question.

The Fellowship may fit if you want guidance turning that curiosity into work. The Challenge may fit if you already enjoy investigating a question independently. Its page describes a format that allows students with less formal research experience to compete. Neither choice requires you to pretend you know more than you do.

Your schedule is tight

Do not assume that an individual competition has no time commitment. Developing an idea, checking evidence and preparing a pitch still take work. A cohort adds scheduled participation to your own project effort.

Check the current schedules on both pages against schoolwork and other commitments. If you cannot make room for either, waiting is a reasonable choice. You do not have to fit both into the same stretch of school.

Can you do both?

You can consider both. Doing them one after the other gives each one its own space. It also lets you decide whether you still want the second experience after finishing the first.

Doing both in the same season needs a closer check. Both pages list Saturday schedules, so sessions may overlap. Check the selected cohorts before committing. Do not assume that being online removes a clash.

Also, do not assume that a Fellowship project can be reused as a Challenge entry, or the reverse. Ask the team. The entry rules, originality requirements and project expectations need to be checked before you plan around shared work.

If you are comparing competitions more broadly, the guide to pre-med competitions for high school students gives you other formats to consider. You do not have to treat these two programs as your only possible choices.

What neither can do

Neither program, nor any prize, guarantees admission anywhere.

A project or a pitch is work you have done. It is not proof that you must become a doctor, and it does not replace school requirements or a university's own selection process.

You can finish either experience and decide you want to explore something else. That is not a reason to hide what you learned about your interests. Pick the format for the work you want to try, not for a promised result that neither program can offer.

How to decide in five minutes

  1. 1.Write one sentence about what you want to do next: build a project with guidance, or develop an idea to pitch independently.
  2. 2.Compare the working setup in the table. Choose the one you would actually use, not the one you think sounds impressive.
  3. 3.Open the Challenge entry page and the Fellowship cohort page. Check the page for current details, including schedules, fees and commitments.
  4. 4.If you still feel unsure, look at a free masterclass before committing to a program.
  5. 5.Write down one unanswered question. You can book a conversation with the team to ask it. You do not need to arrive with a decision already made.

You are choosing a starting point, not a permanent identity. Want guidance now? Start there. Want to put one idea before judges? Start there instead. Neither is the better program for everyone.

Questions you might still have

Can I enter the Challenge without doing the Fellowship?

Yes. The Challenge accepts individual entries from Grades 8 to 12. Its listed entry rules do not require the Fellowship. Read the Challenge page for current details before entering.

Which fits Grade 8?

Both include Grade 8. Choose the Fellowship if you want guidance while building a project. Choose the Challenge if you want to develop and pitch one idea independently. Being eligible does not mean you have to start now.

Can I do both in the same season?

Check the selected cohorts before committing. Both pages list Saturday schedules, so sessions may overlap. Doing them one after the other is another option. Ask the team about timing and whether any work can be used across the two programs.

Do I need medical knowledge to start either?

You do not need to arrive as an expert. The Challenge describes a pitch format that lets students with less formal research experience compete, and the Fellowship offers mentor guidance. If you are unsure about your starting point, ask the team what preparation they expect.